What follows is another debate that took place when I posted a status update in an effort to start a dialog. I wasn’t expecting this to go as far as it did. But what follows is some seriously funny stuff.
Patriot In Exile is proud to be on the liberal watchlists. They can’t silence our voice so they try to scare us with name calling. All that does is fuel the fire.
TR
YOU NAZI! YOU MOBSTER! Hey wait a minute, I guess I am one TOO!!!!! LOL!
Patriot In Exile
I wear that moniker like a badge of honor.
Lib Father-In-Law
How do you know?
TR
AMEN!!!
Patriot In Exile
I am sure my fb rants have been sent to flag@whitehouse.gov.
Lib Father-In-Law
Isn’t that the Secret Service list?
Patriot In Exile
Nope. Linda Douglas has asked for people to turn in any conversations, website or emails that seem “fishy” regarding “misinformation” on HR3200. Sounds like Castro’s goons in the 60’s.
Lib Father-In-Law
What’s HR3200?
Patriot In Exile
That’s funny.
Lib Father-In-Law
I really didn’t know. Mom found it and it is 1017 pages. I assume you have read the entire bill and not somebody’s blog summary?
Patriot In Exile
I am on page 450. It is a very difficult read. There is a lot of ambiguity and the language can be interpreted many different ways.
Also trying to read the UN Charter on Children’s Rights. That one just makes me sick to my stomach.
Pagan Gin
what’s wrong with the Un’s Children’s rights thing…never heard of it.
Patriot In Exile
Just that it allows for other nations to dictate how we raise our children, starts to take away the parent’s right to home school their child(ren), and gives more power to school officials to decide if the parents are “abusing” their children by taking corrective measures for wrong doings. It is a scary thing and Obama is all for it.
Libby CB
Let me know when you find the right wing’s scare tactic, “death panels,” in that document. I’ve yet to find it.
Libby CB
I just read the UN’s Convention on the Rights of the Child, and I don’t see where you get your points of other nations telling us how to raise our children, whether or not we can home school, and gives public schools the right to determine if children are abused by their parents?!!? Can you cite the exact wording of the document because, like I said, I’m not comprehending it as you are.
Patriot In Exile
Nothing yet. Just the end of life stuff. But, if we follow Oregon’s model, then we may have something to worry about.
Also, let me know when the actual reform talk begins. All I see so far in this bill is entitlement. Hearing Obama speak today makes me think that our system is so bad that we are bleeding people to cure diseases. It seems that there are some scare tactics being used on the “left” as well.
So, you have read the entire thing? All sections and pages? When I get back to the room I will be glad to point it out.
Southern CB
Well I don’t know what HR3200 is but I know I’m in there but don’t know which page. I do know that Jesus saved my soul, I will raise my family according to the Bible & I know 7.62×39 & 45 APC very well so screw them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Patriot In Exile
Requested information on UN Charter for Human Rights.
GENERAL COMMENT No. 5 (2003)
General measures of implementation of the Convention on
the Rights of the Child (arts. 4, 42 and 44, para. 6).
In the Introduction is states:
“When a State ratifies the Convention on the Rights of the Child, it takes on obligations under international law to implement it.”
http://bit.ly/16YOg7
The only law we, in the USA, need to follow is that ordained in the US Constitution (much to the dismay of Justice Ginsberg) and by God Himself.
Innocent Gibby
hmmm!
Patriot In Exile
UN Charter regarding Corporal Punishment.
GENERAL COMMENT No. 8 (2006)
The right of the child to protection from corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading forms of punishment (arts. 19; 28, para. 2; and 37, inter alia)
Page 11, Number 43: “It is essential that the prohibition of all corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading punishment, and the sanctions that may be imposed if it is inflicted, should be well disseminated to children and to all those working with or for children in all settings. Monitoring disciplinary systems and the treatment of children must be part of the sustained supervision of all institutions and
placements which is required by the Convention.”
http://bit.ly/3NawGc
Patriot In Exile
On June 11, 2009 a report on home education in England by Graham Badman, a former Managing Director of Children, Families and Education in the County of Kent, was accepted in full by the British Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families. The report makes the case that homeschooling should be extensively regulated in England. He cited Article 29 of the UNCRC he proposed the following:
That designated local authority officers should:
- have the right of access to the home
- have the right to speak with each child alone.
And:
That a requirement is placed upon local authorities to secure the monitoring of the effectiveness of elective home education.
Mr. Badman’s rationale for placing the state in charge of determining the effectiveness of a home education (i.e. deciding which curriculum is used) is based on Article 29 of the UNCRC.
The Badman report is a stark reminder of how government officials in an English-speaking democracy have interpreted the UNCRC.
Patriot In Exile
I am sure you will argue these points I have made. It is no surprise that there is a separation between home schooling and public school sentiment. The overall right of raising the child lies with the parent. We cannot deny that there is some indoctrination that takes place in classrooms. The example of the class in NC where the teacher chided the students who stated they would vote for McCain is a prime example. I can provide that video if you would like.
The rights of the parent are slowly eroding. The UNCRC will do to parents rights what the Typhoon did to Taiwan this week.
Southern CB
I can’t remember where it is but there is a verse in the Bible that says the father who loves his child will chasten after him but the father who does not hateth his son. Or something like that. Of course we’ve all heard the verse that says “Spare not the rod to spoil the child”
Southern CB
Boy PiE, your wall fills up fast! LOL! Your as good at stirring th pot as I am or better LOL!!
Patriot In Exile
For those who want to read Mr. Badman’s (appropriate name) report, go here. http://bit.ly/EU9zS
Lefty Jan
29. Some raise faith-based justifications for corporal punishment, suggesting that certain
interpretations of religious texts not only justify its use, but provide a duty to use it. Freedom of religious belief is upheld for everyone in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (art. 18), but practice of a religion or belief must be consistent with respect for others’ human dignity and physical integrity. Freedom to practise one’s religion or belief may be legitimately limited in order to protect the fundamental rights and freedoms of others. In certain States, the Committee has found that children, in some cases from a very young age, in other cases from the time that they are judged to have reached puberty, may be sentenced to punishments of extreme violence, including stoning and amputation, prescribed under certain interpretations of religious law. Such punishments plainly violate the Convention and other international human rights standards.
Lefty Jan
But again some things are not so bad to have in there. Looking out or children is not a bad thing and like with all bills or anything with government you sometimes end up taking the good with the bad. I am not saying that is a good thing just a reality.
Patriot In Exile
Lefty Jan, the problem here is that a lot is left up to interpretation. Also, there have been numerous cases where children were taken away from their parents because someone at school heard the child was spanked. I agree children should not be in abusive situations. However, the parent has the right to discipline their child for a wrong doing. Google Shelia Marie Sumey and Washington State. She was 13 when her parents grounded her for doing drugs and being sexually active. A school counselor told her she could be liberated and got the courts involved. CPS removed her from the home and her parents, even though the judge believed they were right, lost her to the State.
I do not accept good with the bad when bad means some idiot State or Federal bureaucrat can come in to my home at a whim and take my child because I disagree with government control of our lives. I believe taking the bad with the good is what has gotten us where we are today. Too many people remained silent for too long.
Southern CB
Yep I had DSS investigate me cause someone @ church of all places found out I spanked my kids & called & said I beat my kids & wife & they came out & had to see my children & wife’s naked bodies to see if I was beating them!!! I told the social worker that I now knew exactly what a woman feels like when she says she feels violated!! The law in NC protects the one who made the claim & will not ID them!!! But when DSS finished & sent me a letter saying they found no cause they said they also said the person who accused me would get the same letter & have 30 days to file a criminal charge against me. The social worker called me & said if they did she would testify to the fact that my home was the environment every child should grow up in!!!! Praise GOD for watching over us!!! It took my wife over a year before she would talk to anyone or let even friends & family in our home again!!
Texas Joe
Southern CB, People that make those accusations are no better than the dog poo that is on my boots. To falsely make accusations like that and destroy another persons sanity, is in itself abuse, but the good ol’ big bother doesn’t want that.
Pagan Gin
Well the sad truth about ‘home schooling’ is we got leftwing-nuts and right-wingnuts home schooling their kids and brainwashing them with all kinds of nonesence. Extremists on one side teaching kids that the universe is only 5000 years old, and Earth is the only planet with life in it….and ones on the other extreme teaching kids that smoking pot leads to enlightenment. Some teaching woman shouldn’t wear pants or make-up…some teaching everyone should go nude….both extremes are wackos…and both extremes have no business teaching such crap to kids who are sheltered form ‘the real world.’ Being a Pagan myself…many of ‘us’ homeschool and it’s bad for kids to be schooled only with ‘others like them’ and be always under the thumb of over protective over controlling parents. Kids need to learn to think for themselves, learn all things not just what mommy or their preacher says they can learn. Then make up their OWN minds if they believe what their parents believe.
Southern CB
Ginger all though I may not agree with your views me being a Christian I do see you have a valid point. But I also do not believe children are mature enough or wise enough to decide what’s right & wrong & choose how to believe until they are older then of course they have the right to make those choices. My self as a Christian try to raise mine according to the teachings of the Bible which plainly says I should. But it also plainly says that child has to make the choice on their own when they reach the “the age of accountability”. That’s just simply means we are to raise them as Christian but when they are old enough to understand it’s up to them cause we neither have the right or ability to decide such things for anyone including our children. The Bible also teaches to teach them about the world & what’s out there & they are other beliefs. We do our best to try to educate our kids on what is popular belief & what we believe & what others believe & they will have to choose as they grow.
Lefty Jan
PiE I understand your point but I think that this is still a good concept and idea to have protection for children. Especially after reading this article
.http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/africa/08/11/congo.rape/index.html
It is a horrible world we live in that this goes on. I think that this is the focus that should be on the children. I think homeschooling should not even really be an issue as there are greater risks to children these days. It is a shame that we as people have no say into what goes into these conventions, bills or anything. I wish that there was a way for all our voices to be heard.
Pagan Gin
good for your kids Southern CB, but not all parents are as reasonable, as I said on BOTH extremes we have parents brainwashing kids with stuff they need to know is not the ‘accepted’ norm…much less ‘fact.’ And on the punishment issue…alas….many a holy book…from various faiths…can be used to justify beating a child, stoning one, killing one cutting off his hand…cutting off her privates…just because your or anyone else’s holy book says it…does not make it ‘right’ People need to stop taking all holy books so word for word literal. All faiths have some good dogma, and all faiths alas have some bad dogma. Schools should be multifaith or no faith, not any one faith.
Lefty Jan
Wow this sure got off topic. PiE you sure know how to stir the pot and get people’s opinions out there.
Patriot In Exile is proud to be on the liberal watchlists. They can’t silence our voice so they try to scare us with name calling. All that does is fuel the fire.
YOU NAZI! YOU MOBSTER! Hey wait a minute, I guess I am one TOO!!!!! LOL!
Patriot In Exile
I wear that moniker like a badge of honor.
Lib Father-In-Law
How do you know?
AMEN!!!
I am sure my fb rants have been sent to flag@whitehouse.gov.
Isn’t that the Secret Service list?
Nope. Linda Douglas has asked for people to turn in any conversations, website or emails that seem “fishy” regarding “misinformation” on HR3200. Sounds like Castro’s goons in the 60’s.
What’s HR3200?
That’s funny.
I really didn’t know. Mom found it and it is 1017 pages. I assume you have read the entire bill and not somebody’s blog summary?
I am on page 450. It is a very difficult read. There is a lot of ambiguity and the language can be interpreted many different ways.
Also trying to read the UN Charter on Children’s Rights. That one just makes me sick to my stomach.
what’s wrong with the Un’s Children’s rights thing…never heard of it.
Just that it allows for other nations to dictate how we raise our children, starts to take away the parent’s right to home school their child(ren), and gives more power to school officials to decide if the parents are “abusing” their children by taking corrective measures for wrong doings. It is a scary thing and Obama is all for it.
Let me know when you find the right wing’s scare tactic, “death panels,” in that document. I’ve yet to find it.
I just read the UN’s Convention on the Rights of the Child, and I don’t see where you get your points of other nations telling us how to raise our children, whether or not we can home school, and gives public schools the right to determine if children are abused by their parents?!!? Can you cite the exact wording of the document because, like I said, I’m not comprehending it as you are.
Nothing yet. Just the end of life stuff. But, if we follow Oregon’s model, then we may have something to worry about.
Also, let me know when the actual reform talk begins. All I see so far in this bill is entitlement. Hearing Obama speak today makes me think that our system is so bad that we are bleeding people to cure diseases. It seems that there are some scare tactics being used on the “left” as well.
So, you have read the entire thing? All sections and pages? When I get back to the room I will be glad to point it out.
Well I don’t know what HR3200 is but I know I’m in there but don’t know which page. I do know that Jesus saved my soul, I will raise my family according to the Bible & I know 7.62×39 & 45 APC very well so screw them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Requested information on UN Charter for Human Rights.
GENERAL COMMENT No. 5 (2003)
General measures of implementation of the Convention on
the Rights of the Child (arts. 4, 42 and 44, para. 6).
In the Introduction is states:
“When a State ratifies the Convention on the Rights of the Child, it takes on obligations under international law to implement it.”
http://bit.ly/16YOg7
The only law we, in the USA, need to follow is that ordained in the US Constitution (much to the dismay of Justice Ginsberg) and by God Himself.
hmmm!
UN Charter regarding Corporal Punishment.
GENERAL COMMENT No. 8 (2006)
The right of the child to protection from corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading forms of punishment (arts. 19; 28, para. 2; and 37, inter alia)
Page 11, Number 43: “It is essential that the prohibition of all corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading punishment, and the sanctions that may be imposed if it is inflicted, should be well disseminated to children and to all those working with or for children in all settings. Monitoring disciplinary systems and the treatment of children must be part of the sustained supervision of all institutions and
placements which is required by the Convention.”
http://bit.ly/3NawGc
On June 11, 2009 a report on home education in England by Graham Badman, a former Managing Director of Children, Families and Education in the County of Kent, was accepted in full by the British Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families. The report makes the case that homeschooling should be extensively regulated in England. He cited Article 29 of the UNCRC he proposed the following:
That designated local authority officers should:
- have the right of access to the home
- have the right to speak with each child alone.
And:
That a requirement is placed upon local authorities to secure the monitoring of the effectiveness of elective home education.
Mr. Badman’s rationale for placing the state in charge of determining the effectiveness of a home education (i.e. deciding which curriculum is used) is based on Article 29 of the UNCRC.
The Badman report is a stark reminder of how government officials in an English-speaking democracy have interpreted the UNCRC.
I am sure you will argue these points I have made. It is no surprise that there is a separation between home schooling and public school sentiment. The overall right of raising the child lies with the parent. We cannot deny that there is some indoctrination that takes place in classrooms. The example of the class in NC where the teacher chided the students who stated they would vote for McCain is a prime example. I can provide that video if you would like.
The rights of the parent are slowly eroding. The UNCRC will do to parents rights what the Typhoon did to Taiwan this week.
I can’t remember where it is but there is a verse in the Bible that says the father who loves his child will chasten after him but the father who does not hateth his son. Or something like that. Of course we’ve all heard the verse that says “Spare not the rod to spoil the child”
Boy PiE, your wall fills up fast! LOL! Your as good at stirring th pot as I am or better LOL!!
For those who want to read Mr. Badman’s (appropriate name) report, go here. http://bit.ly/EU9zS
29. Some raise faith-based justifications for corporal punishment, suggesting that certain
interpretations of religious texts not only justify its use, but provide a duty to use it. Freedom of religious belief is upheld for everyone in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (art. 18), but practice of a religion or belief must be consistent with respect for others’ human dignity and physical integrity. Freedom to practise one’s religion or belief may be legitimately limited in order to protect the fundamental rights and freedoms of others. In certain States, the Committee has found that children, in some cases from a very young age, in other cases from the time that they are judged to have reached puberty, may be sentenced to punishments of extreme violence, including stoning and amputation, prescribed under certain interpretations of religious law. Such punishments plainly violate the Convention and other international human rights standards.
But again some things are not so bad to have in there. Looking out or children is not a bad thing and like with all bills or anything with government you sometimes end up taking the good with the bad. I am not saying that is a good thing just a reality.
Lefty Jan, the problem here is that a lot is left up to interpretation. Also, there have been numerous cases where children were taken away from their parents because someone at school heard the child was spanked. I agree children should not be in abusive situations. However, the parent has the right to discipline their child for a wrong doing. Google Shelia Marie Sumey and Washington State. She was 13 when her parents grounded her for doing drugs and being sexually active. A school counselor told her she could be liberated and got the courts involved. CPS removed her from the home and her parents, even though the judge believed they were right, lost her to the State.
I do not accept good with the bad when bad means some idiot State or Federal bureaucrat can come in to my home at a whim and take my child because I disagree with government control of our lives. I believe taking the bad with the good is what has gotten us where we are today. Too many people remained silent for too long.
Yep I had DSS investigate me cause someone @ church of all places found out I spanked my kids & called & said I beat my kids & wife & they came out & had to see my children & wife’s naked bodies to see if I was beating them!!! I told the social worker that I now knew exactly what a woman feels like when she says she feels violated!! The law in NC protects the one who made the claim & will not ID them!!! But when DSS finished & sent me a letter saying they found no cause they said they also said the person who accused me would get the same letter & have 30 days to file a criminal charge against me. The social worker called me & said if they did she would testify to the fact that my home was the environment every child should grow up in!!!! Praise GOD for watching over us!!! It took my wife over a year before she would talk to anyone or let even friends & family in our home again!!
Texas Joe
Chris, People that make those accusations are no better than the dog poo that is on my boots. To falsely make accusations like that and destroy another persons sanity, is in itself abuse, but the good ol’ big bother doesn’t want that.
Well the sad truth about ‘home schooling’ is we got leftwing-nuts and right-wingnuts home schooling their kids and brainwashing them with all kinds of nonesence. Extremists on one side teaching kids that the universe is only 5000 years old, and Earth is the only planet with life in it….and ones on the other extreme teaching kids that smoking pot leads to enlightenment. Some teaching woman shouldn’t wear pants or make-up…some teaching everyone should go nude….both extremes are wackos…and both extremes have no business teaching such crap to kids who are sheltered form ‘the real world.’ Being a Pagan myself…many of ‘us’ homeschool and it’s bad for kids to be schooled only with ‘others like them’ and be always under the thumb of over protective over controlling parents. Kids need to learn to think for themselves, learn all things not just what mommy or their preacher says they can learn. Then make up their OWN minds if they believe what their parents believe.
Ginger all though I may not agree with your views me being a Christian I do see you have a valid point. But I also do not believe children are mature enough or wise enough to decide what’s right & wrong & choose how to believe until they are older then of course they have the right to make those choices. My self as a Christian try to raise mine according to the teachings of the Bible which plainly says I should. But it also plainly says that child has to make the choice on their own when they reach the “the age of accountability”. Thats just simply means we are to raise them as Christian but when they are old enough to understand it’s up to them cause we neither have the right or ability to decide such things for anyone including our children. The Bible also teaches to teach them about the world & what’s out there & they are other beliefs. We do our best to try to educate our kids on what is popular belief & what we believe & what others believe & they will have to choose as they grow.
PiE I understand your point but I think that this is still a good concept and idea to have protection for children. Especially after reading this article
.http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/africa/08/11/congo.rape/index.html
It is a horrible world we live in that this goes on. I think that this is the focus that should be on the children. I think homeschooling should not even really be an issue as there are greater risks to children these days. It is a shame that we as people have no say into what goes into these conventions, bills or anything. I wish that there was a way for all our voices to be heard.
good for your kids Chris, but not all parents are as reasonable, as I said on BOTH extremes we have parents brainwashing kids with stuff they need to know is not the ‘accepted’ norm…much less ‘fact.’ And on the punishment issue…alas….many a holy book…from various faiths…can be used to justify beating a child, stoning one, killing one cutting off his hand…cutting off her privates…just because your or anyone else’s holy book says it…does not make it ‘right’ People need to stop taking all holy books so word for word literal. All faiths have some good dogma, and all faiths alas have some bad dogma. Schools should be multifaith or no faith, not any one faith.
Wow this sure got off topic. PiE you sure know how to stir the pot and get people’s opinions out there.